Canadian peat extraction numbers released this fall show wide regional variation, but the Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss Association says careful inventory management should still allow producers to meet customer needs. For growers, the more useful takeaway is not a shortage warning but a prompt to ask how resilient their growing-media strategy is when a key material becomes harder or more expensive to secure.
The CSPMA's Sept. 17 report, covering conditions through Aug. 31, put extraction at 56% of expected levels in Alberta, 79% in Manitoba, 90% in Saskatchewan, 77% on Québec's North and South Shores, 70% in Southern New Brunswick, 85% in Northern New Brunswick, and 90% in Ontario. Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador, and Nova Scotia were reported as significantly below expected levels.
What the Numbers Do and Don't Mean
CSPMA attributes much of the shortfall to wet weather, and it stresses that careful inventory management should let producers meet customer requirements. That distinction matters: the figures are not a declaration of peat shortage. The association's "expected extraction" is also not a measure of how much available peatland was harvested. It is the amount producers calculated they needed for the season — market requirements plus the desired year-end inventory buffer, less inventory carried in. It is a planning target, not a harvest report.
The bigger point is that an agricultural raw material harvested outdoors will never be fully insulated from weather. Peat is only one part of a wider supply picture. Climate affects harvest and biomass availability; labor affects harvesting, processing, and transportation; and freight can change the economics of a material well before its FOB price moves.
Freight and Cost Pressure Beyond Peat
Transportation is especially difficult now. The Wall Street Journal reported in late September that U.S. contract trucking rates averaged $3.11 per mile in August, including fuel surcharges, up 29% from a year earlier. Diesel, driver availability, rail surcharges, and ocean freight all add volatility. For bulky inputs such as growing media, delivered cost can quickly change the answer to a sourcing decision.
Dr. Charlie Hall has made a similar argument from the broader grower-cost perspective. In a recent interview, he emphasized supply-chain agility, backup suppliers, and working-capital discipline as growers plan for 2027. His Index of Prices Paid by Growers is useful because the cheapest input on paper is not necessarily the lowest-risk or lowest-cost choice once freight, inventory, and operational impacts are included.
The implication is that raw-material selection should stop being a once-a-year purchasing exercise and start being a risk-management and production-design decision.
Start With Crop Character, Then Back Into Ingredients
Growing media is often built in the opposite direction from what makes sense. Mixes frequently start with what is available — peat, coir, bark, wood fiber, perlite, or another familiar component — and then a formulation is built around those ingredients. A better starting point is the crop: what character does the root zone need? How much water holding, how much air porosity, how much structural stability across the crop cycle? How must the material rewet? What buffering and chemistry can the crop and irrigation program tolerate? How uniform does it need to be for automation? Once those requirements are clear, the ingredients and percentages that create that character can follow.
This matters because the raw-material toolbox is expanding. Wageningen University & Research's 2026 work on the future of growing media identifies market-accepted materials such as coir, coniferous wood fiber, bark, compost, and perlite, but also less familiar candidates including other plant fibers, biochars, co-composts, and reused growing media. The researchers note that many new materials require processing, sanitization, and stabilization before they become reliable horticultural inputs. Availability is not the same as suitability — but suitability is increasingly something the industry can engineer.
Revisit Materials Passed Over
Processing technology has continued to improve across coir, wood fiber, bark, and other biomass streams. Materials that were too inconsistent, too wet, too coarse, too salty, too difficult to handle, or simply too expensive several years ago may deserve another look. The same applies to regional agricultural residues that can be cleaned, screened, fiberized, composted, or otherwise processed into more consistent ingredients.
This does not mean replacing a proven substrate simply because something new exists. It means knowing what else is out there before it is needed. A material also does not have to make up 30% or 40% of a formulation to be useful; in some systems a 5% or 10% inclusion may be enough to change cost, water behavior, structure, rewetting, or supply exposure. The right inclusion rate is a crop- and system-specific question, and any new component needs to be trialed and validated before commercial adoption. Small trials become strategic: testing an alternative wood fiber, or revisiting rice hulls, bark fractions, coir products, or locally available biomass, builds knowledge before a supply disruption forces the decision.
Local and Global as a Portfolio, Not a Choice
Interest in sourcing closer to home is understandable. Regional materials can reduce transportation exposure and add flexibility, particularly when they can be processed near the point of use. But local is not automatically better, just as imported is not automatically risky.
Coir, for example, travels a long distance yet can offer characteristics that are difficult to reproduce with some local materials. Peat remains an extraordinarily important and effective growing-media component. Wood fiber and bark can contribute well where feedstock and processing are right. Other biomass streams may become more useful as processing improves.
A more resilient strategy is likely to be a portfolio: dependable core materials, strong supplier relationships, some regional options, some globally sourced options, and enough formulation knowledge to adjust without losing the root-zone character the crop requires.
Using This Season as a Planning Signal
The lesson from this year's Canadian peat harvest is not that growers should move away from peat — CSPMA itself says inventory management should allow producers to meet customer requirements. The lesson is that the conditions behind raw materials can change quickly while crops still have to be produced on schedule. Weather, labor, freight, tariffs, and supply-chain disruptions over recent years have shown that yesterday's dependable supply pattern is not guaranteed to remain tomorrow's.
Growing-media demand is also growing. Wageningen research projects global demand rising substantially toward 2050, which means the industry will need a broader basket of materials and more processing capacity, not simply a different winner in the peat-versus-coir-versus-wood-fiber debate.
For growers planning 2027, that suggests a few practical questions: Which raw materials are most exposed in the current formulation? What is their true delivered cost? Which characteristics are essential to the crop? What other ingredients could deliver part of that function? And which should be trialed now? The best time to build flexibility into a growing-media program is while choices remain.
